Understanding Your Investment Returns: A Guide to Calculating Portfolio Performance
Calculating your investment returns doesn’t require a complex finance degree. A few basic principles are all you need to become a more informed investor, even if you’re not a math enthusiast. Understanding your portfolio’s performance is not just a smart move; it’s essential for making well-informed decisions about your financial future and feeling empowered in your financial journey.
Investment returns are calculated by comparing your assets’ initial and current values while factoring in any dividends or interest earned. While it’s impossible to predict your portfolio’s exact performance, understanding how to calculate your returns can help you gauge each asset’s potential gain. It also allows you to evaluate factors such as downside risk, market conditions, and how long it will take for your investments to achieve returns, giving you a deeper knowledge of your portfolio’s performance.
Key Takeaways:
- Calculating your returns begins with knowing each investment’s initial cost and current value.
- Single investment calculations offer insights into individual asset performance, which can help you identify profitable or underperforming investments.
- Portfolio return calculations provide an overview of how well your overall investment strategy works, guiding you in diversification and risk management decisions.
- Time-Weighted Return (TWR) and Money-Weighted Return (MWR) are standard methods for calculating returns. Knowing the differences between them is crucial for evaluating your portfolio.
- Annualizing your returns lets you compare multi-period returns across different portfolios or potential investments.
Calculating Returns for a Single Investment
Focusing on individual assets is the best way to understand your portfolio’s performance. A primary metric to calculate is the return on investment (ROI), which helps you determine how effectively an asset grows your money.
Example: Suppose you bought a dividend-paying stock for $1,000 and sold it a year later for $1,500. Over the year, you earned $20 in dividends and paid $5 in trading fees.
- Initial cost: $1,000 + $5 = $1,005
- Current value: $1,500
- Add dividends: $1,500 + $20 = $1,520
- Subtract initial cost: $1,520 – $1,005 = $515
- Calculate ROI: $515 ÷ $1,005 = 51.24%
This method shows how much you’ve earned or lost on a particular asset.
Calculating Returns for an Entire Portfolio
As you diversify your portfolio with stocks, bonds, real estate, and more, calculating the returns for each asset becomes more complex. Tracking each investment’s dividends, interest, fees, and taxes requires a spreadsheet to calculate overall portfolio returns.
To calculate portfolio returns, you’ll need to know:
- The total cost of each investment (including fees and commissions).
- The historical returns for each investment (including dividends and interest).
- The portfolio weight of each investment (as a percentage of the total portfolio value).
Once you have this data, multiply the ROI of each asset by its portfolio weight. Summing these values gives the total portfolio return.
Time-Weighted Returns (TWR)
Time-weighted return (TWR) evaluates your portfolio’s performance while ignoring external cash flows like deposits and withdrawals. TWR focuses purely on the investments’ performance, clearly showing how well your portfolio is managed.
Example: You invest $1,000 at the start of the year. Mid-year, the value grows to $1,200, and you add $500, bringing the total to $1,700. By year-end, the total is $1,600.
- For the first half of the year, your rate of return is: (1,200 – 1,000) ÷ 1,000 = 20%
- For the second half: (1,600 – 1,700) ÷ 1,700 = -5.9%
- Total TWR: (1 + 0.20) × (1 – 0.059) = 13% for the year.
TWR is particularly useful for comparing portfolios and managers but does not account for personal investment timing.
Money-Weighted Returns (MWR)
Money-weighted return (MWR) factors in the timing and amount of contributions and withdrawals, offering a personalized view of investment performance. Unlike TWR, MWR represents the portfolio’s internal rate of return (IRR).
MWR calculates the return based on the investor’s experience, but it may not be ideal for comparing different portfolios or fund managers since it accounts for the impact of cash flows.
Factors to Consider Beyond TWR and MWR
Holding Period Return (HPR)
Holding period return (HPR) measures your return over a specific period, accounting for capital gains and any income from dividends or interest. The formula for HPR is:
HPR = (Income + (End Value - Initial Value)) / Initial Value
HPR is especially useful for comparing assets with different holding periods.
Adjusting for Cash Flows
When adjusting for cash flows like deposits and withdrawals, consider using the Modified Dietz Method or the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) to get a more precise picture of your portfolio’s performance.
- Modified Dietz Method: Weights cash flows by the time they’ve been in the portfolio.
- Internal Rate of Return (IRR): The discount rate that makes the net present value of all cash flows zero.
Annualizing Returns
To compare multi-period returns, annualizing them gives a clearer view of how an investment performs over a year. It helps you standardize returns and compare them with other investments across different periods.
Annualizing considers compounding, but it does not account for volatility or risk.
Example: Portfolio Return Calculation
Suppose you started the year with $10,000 in your account, ending with $13,350. You earned $500 in dividends and paid $150 in fees.
- Net Gain: (13,350 – 10,000) + 500 – 150 = 3,700
- ROI: 3,700 ÷ 10,000 = 37%
If you made an additional deposit of $5,000 mid-year, you must adjust the calculation to account for that cash flow.
Why Portfolio Return Calculations Are Important
Reviewing your portfolio returns allows you to assess your strategy’s effectiveness. It highlights which investments deliver the expected returns and guides decisions about rebalancing your assets.
Choosing the Right Benchmarks
Selecting appropriate benchmarks is essential for understanding how your portfolio compares to the market or other funds. For instance, the Nasdaq index might be your best benchmark if you primarily invest in tech stocks.
The Bottom Line
Calculating your portfolio’s returns helps you understand which investments are performing well and which need attention. Regularly evaluating your portfolio can refine your strategy to align with your financial goals. Although brokers offer tools for calculating returns, knowing the different methods will help you choose the right approach for your needs.
Discussion about this post