Money Market Funds vs. Money Market Accounts (MMAs) vs. Savings Accounts: A Comparative Analysis
Part of the series
- Guide to Savings Accounts ▾
Money market funds, money market accounts (MMAs), and standard savings accounts serve as liquid cash repositories, offering easy access to your money whenever needed. Although many traditional savings accounts provide minimal interest rates, money market funds or MMAs can sometimes offer better returns. Unlike savings, money market funds and accounts may also provide check-writing capabilities. It’s important to note that money market funds are investment products, while money market accounts are bank products, which means they have different risk and return profiles.
Key Insights
- Money Market Funds: These mutual funds pool money from multiple investors into various low-risk investments.
- Savings Accounts and Money Market Accounts: These bank products provide interest-bearing, easily accessible deposits.
- Insurance: Savings accounts and money market deposit accounts are insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) or the National Credit Union Association (NCUA), while money market funds do not have FDIC insurance and can be susceptible to market runs.
- Returns: Money market funds generally offer higher returns than money market accounts.
Comparing Money Market Funds, Money Market Accounts, and Savings Accounts
Feature | Money Market Fund | Money Market Account | Savings Account |
---|---|---|---|
Provider | Investment firms | Banks and credit unions | Banks and credit unions |
Type | Mutual fund | Deposit | Deposit |
Requirements | Often required | Often required | Sometimes required |
Management Fee | Always | Not usually | Not usually |
Interest Rate | Variable | Variable | Variable |
Insurance (up to $250,000) | No | Yes | Yes |
Tax-Free Returns Available | Yes | No | No |
Check Writing & ATM Access | No | Yes | No |
Money Market Mutual Funds
Offered by brokerages, investment companies, and financial services firms, money market mutual funds pool money from numerous investors and invest it in high-quality, short-term securities. Despite being investments, these funds function similarly to on-demand cash accounts, offering better returns than typical savings accounts.
Money market funds often have initial investment and balance requirements alongside transaction fees. Unlike bank accounts, these funds carry an expense ratio—a fee based on a percentage of the fund’s management expenses.
The FDIC does not insure these accounts, but they are regulated by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). Instead, the Securities Investor Protection Corp. (SIPC) insures money market funds up to $500,000, including $250,000 in cash.
Depending on the fund’s investments, dividends earned from money market funds can be taxable or tax-free. While they may not yield as high returns as the stock market, they pose lower risks and less volatility.
However, like any investment, returns are not guaranteed, and money market funds have historically been susceptible to investor panics. The SEC has introduced new regulations aimed at preventing future crises, such as [specific regulations or measures].
The performance of money market funds is closely linked to the interest rates set by the Federal Reserve. Depending on the fees, a money market fund may not outperform a savings account. Therefore, it’s crucial to thoroughly research before moving money into such funds.
Money Market Accounts (MMAs)
Money market accounts (MMAs), while similar in name to money market mutual funds, function more like savings accounts. They combine the features of a savings account with some checking account privileges, such as check-writing and debit card access.
MMAs are interest-bearing accounts held at banks or credit unions. Deposits are insured up to $250,000 by the FDIC (for banks) or NCUA (for credit unions). The interest rates on MMAs often depend on the account balance; higher balances may earn higher interest rates than regular savings accounts.
Although the Federal Reserve removed Regulation D’s restriction on the number of withdrawals per month in 2020, some banks may still limit access to funds in an MMA. It’s essential to ask your bank about any rules or restrictions associated with your account.
The similarity between money market funds and accounts lies in their investment in short-term debt instruments, which make up the “money market.” These include certificates of deposit (CDs), government securities, and commercial paper—investments that are not typically part of savings accounts.
Savings Accounts
Savings accounts, widely available at banks, credit unions, and other financial institutions, are a secure and convenient way to store money for future use, such as saving for emergency expenses. Their safety and convenience provide a sense of security and ease to the account holders.
Savings accounts provide a way to earn interest, allowing your money to grow. While they usually offer lower interest rates than other savings vehicles, including money market deposit accounts or mutual funds, with some research, you can find higher-yielding savings accounts that align with your financial goals. This potential for growth can instill a sense of optimism and hope in the account holders.
Like money market deposit accounts, savings accounts are insured by the FDIC or NCUA up to $250,000. In contrast, money market funds are insured by SIPC up to $500,000, including $250,000 in cash.
Special Considerations
While money market funds, savings accounts, and money market accounts are generally considered low-risk, the tradeoff for safety is a lower return potential. You might earn less than you would with riskier investments, such as individual stocks or ETFs, but you also face lower risks of loss.
The returns on money market funds, savings accounts, and money market accounts are variable, influenced by interest rates and the financial institution’s need for deposits. Changes in the Federal Reserve’s policies can lead to fluctuations in interest rates and, subsequently, the earnings from these accounts.
If the interest rates on these accounts do not keep pace with inflation, the actual value of your money could erode over time.
Interest in money market funds, savings accounts, or money market accounts is typically compounded yearly, monthly, or daily. Compounding can significantly impact returns, especially if you maintain a high balance. Compounding is the process where the interest you earn on your initial deposit is added to your balance, and then the next interest payment is calculated based on the increased balance. This means that the more frequently interest is compounded, the more you earn.
Choosing the Right Account for You
Understanding the specifics of each account type can help you avoid high fees, meet minimum balance requirements, and maximize your returns on low-risk savings. This knowledge empowers you and puts you in control of your financial decisions.
When to Choose a Money Market Account
A money market account may be the best option if you have a substantial sum to deposit—at least four figures—and can maintain a high balance over time. You may earn a better yield in return, although some high-yield savings accounts can offer competitive returns.
Higher balances typically earn higher interest rates. Additionally, a money market account allows check-writing and debit card access, making it a versatile choice for those who want these features.
MMAs are ideal for keeping funds you don’t need to access frequently and can stay in the account for a year or more.
When to Choose a Savings Account
Suppose you have a smaller sum (less than $1,000) to deposit and want to avoid maintaining minimum balances or paying fees. In that case, a savings account might be more suitable.
Savings accounts are less tempting to access frequently, making them a better option for short-term goals or parking funds for upcoming expenses, such as a holiday or a significant purchase. Competitive savings accounts sometimes offer interest rates that rival money market accounts.
When to Choose a Money Market Fund
A money market fund might be the right choice for holding short-term funds before significant expenditures or between investments. It can also be a less volatile investment option if you have large sums of cash to diversify beyond traditional banks and riskier stocks.
Money market funds are well-suited for experienced investors or those working with a financial advisor. When choosing a money market fund, consider your risk tolerance, desired returns, and tax implications.
For example, some money market funds offer tax exemptions at the federal and state levels, making them attractive to investors in high-tax states. Others may be taxable but offer higher interest rates or lower expense ratios.
What Are the Alternatives?
Alternatives to money market funds, money market accounts, and savings accounts include:
- Certificates of Deposit (CDs): CDs are time-bound savings accounts that lock up your money for a specified period in exchange for higher interest rates.
- Treasuries: U.S. Treasury bonds, notes, and bills are backed by the government, providing a secure investment option. Like CDs, some Treasuries require you to lock up funds until maturity.
- Bond Funds: These are mutual funds or ETFs that invest in baskets of fixed-income securities, offering various risk profiles and liquidity levels. Bond funds, like money market funds, typically charge an expense ratio.
- High-Interest Checking Accounts: These accounts offer interest rates rivaling or exceeding money market accounts. However, they often come with strict requirements, such as a minimum number of debit card transactions.
How Does a Money Market Account Differ From a CD?
While both money market accounts and CDs are interest-bearing and insured up to $250,000, a money market account provides easy access to your funds, whereas a CD requires you to lock in your money for a specific term. CDs typically offer higher interest rates than MMAs.
How Do I Find a Good Money Market Account?
To find the best money market account, consider the interest rate and factors like:
- Minimum initial deposit
- Balance maintenance requirements
- Accessibility options, such as checks or debit cards
- Monthly withdrawal or transaction limits
- Transaction definitions: What counts as a transaction—ATM withdrawals, purchases, electronic transfers?
- Fees, fines, and penalties
Conclusion
Deciding whether to put your money into a money market fund, a money market deposit account, or a savings account depends on how much you deposit and how you plan to access your money. Other factors include your risk tolerance and preference for a tax-advantaged savings option.
As banks and investment firms compete, interest rates may vary significantly. While money market funds have historically offered the highest returns, insured money market, and savings accounts might now offer competitive rates without management fees or risk of loss. Regardless of your choice, you should spread your money across more than one account type.
Final Thought: Choose the correct account based on your needs and financial goals.
FAQs
- Are money market accounts insured? Yes, money market accounts are insured up to $250,000 by the FDIC (for banks) or NCUA (for credit unions).
- What is the primary difference between a money market fund and a money market account? A money market fund is a mutual fund that invests in short-term, high-quality investments. In contrast, a money market account is a deposit account offered by banks and credit unions.
- Can you lose money in a money market fund? Yes, the FDIC does not insure money market funds and can lose value, though generally considered low-risk.
- Which offers better returns: money market accounts or savings accounts? Money market accounts often offer better returns than savings accounts, but this depends on the institution and the account balance.
- What are the tax implications of money market funds? The returns from money market funds can be taxable or tax-free, depending on the specific investments within the fund.
Part of the series
- Guide to Savings Accounts ▾
Discussion about this post